Alex gendler unravels platos allegory of the cave, found in book vii of the republic. As sontag writes for something to shock us, it has to be novel. Susan sontag audio books, best sellers, author bio. Sontag s 1977 monograph on photography is composed of six named chapters, or essays, which form a weakly related progression from conceptualization through history and implementation, to the thencurrent understanding of photography as a process and an art form. I think nietzsche s philosophy applies more to group morality the allegory of the cave is more a picture of individual enlightenment, perhaps, than group morality, though nietzsche s philosophy does seem to me to appeal to the category of the individual against group morality, so maybe the allegory does apply to nietzsche s thinking, too, in that sense.
Course notes susan sontag, in platos cave, from on. Susan sontag has been a fellow of the american academy since 1993. On photography by susan sontag is a treatise on photography. He goes on to explain the anxiety pain tabula rasa. Humankind lingers unregenerately in platos cave, still reveling, its ageold habit, in mere images of the truth. In platos cave by susan sontag in susan sontags view, both platos cave images and photographs represent mere images of the truth p. But before we discuss platos allegory of the cave, lets talk about this great philosopher first.
Photography, she writes, implies that we know about the world if we accept it as the camera records it. Every page of on photography raises important and exciting questions about its subject and raises them in the best way. Not knowing what the outside world was like or even what a person looked like. Sontag draws an analogy between our viewing of photographs and the prisoners in plato s cave. The essays are of a polemic nature, rather than academic. This is an essay, if you will, of my interpretation of the first chapter in plato s cave of susan sontag s 1977 book, on photography. Rr4susan sontag and platos cave comd advanced photography. Susan sontag s on photography is one of the best studies of photography that you can find. Humankind lingers unregenerately in plato s cave, still reveling, its ageold habit, in mere images of the truth. In platos cave by susan sontag by pyaya cane on prezi. Freedom, stage two out of the cave into daylight socrates. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. In the excerpt from susan sontag s, in plato s cave, sontag uses the allegory of plato s cave to relate to photography in our modern age.
Susan sontag, on photography scrapbooked inquiries. Turn off the lights, close the blinds, and welcome them to platos cave. This is a video by helen oenick covering a chapter in susan sontag s book called in plato s cave. Doc analysis of susan sontags writing on photography. Plato a student of socrates suggested the story of a cave in which youths had been imprisoned from an early age and restrained so as to only see images produced in the fashion of shadow theatre, with no exposure to the real objects that cast them. Find summaries for every chapter, including a on photography chapter summary chart to help you understand the book. And what does the act of taking a picture what desire, or satisfaction does that provide me with. For one thing, there are a great many more images around, claiming our attention. Plato s republic1 the allegory of the cave and now, i said, let me show in a figure how far our nature is enlightened or unenlightened. The parable of the cave minnesota state university moorhead. Susan sontag s on photography book poetry e train susan sontag. Sometimes the chains around our neck are too tight, impossible to break.
Her book is a collection of six essays that explore photography in the deepest of manners. Public intellectual, polymath, provocatrice roundtable discussion with. Sontag s background in philosophy is evident in this argument, as she uses the philosophical definition of understanding a thing and brings plato. Humankind lingers unregenerately in platos cave, still reveling, its ageold habit, in mere images of. She compares the allegory of these shadows to photos and reality, saying that photos are like shadows. This is what this eyeopening allegory can teach us today. Eugene atget brassai walker evans dorothea lange dachau marc riboud diane arbus don mcmullin werner bischof. Susan sontag on photography in platos cave mind benders susan sontag from the book on photography, in plato s cave mind benders. Susan sontag use the metaphor of platos cave to say that you have to experience the world in order for you to know what objects are truly real in a photographed because photos can lie. One of sontag s main observations about photography is that photographs are like the shadows inside the ancient greek philosopher plato s metaphorical cave. Susan sontag in platos cave to collect photographs is to collect the world sontag for sontag the photo is a means of controlling the world and taking ownership of it much as john berger said with relation to painting and, for example, holbeins ambassadors. Platos allegory of the caveplatos allegory of the cave is philosophy that is a notable contribution to the existence of philosophy overall.
January 16, 1933 december 28, 2004 was an american writer, filmmaker, philosopher, teacher, and political activist. For those of you who do not know who susan sontag 1933 2004 was, she was an active author, intellectual, playwright, wellknown cultural figure, and humanitarian. The following links will be useful during your reading of in platos cave. Susan sontag was born in new york city on january 16, 1933. Beyond sounding quite morbid, what exactly did he mean. The allegory of the cave has also allegorical meaning because so many symbolic suggestions are used in this writings. On email protected susan sontag, in plato s cave from the book. Analysis of susan sontag s writing on photography and a critical interpretation of a photograph. Our book summary willingly joins the efforts to educate the population. Find a summary of this and each chapter of on photography. Photos arent reality but they are just frozen moment of something.
Now, however, if someone, using force, were to pull him who had been freed from his chains away from there and to drag him up the caves rough and steep ascent and not to let go of him until. Humankind lingers unregenerately in plato s cave, still reveling, its age. Reading summary 2 in the excerpt from susan sontags in. The article makes several basic observations on how photographs have caused us as humans to evolve in how we see things.
The earliest theory of art, that of the greek philosophers, proposed that art was mimesis, imitation of reality. Sontag explores a collection of claims about photographs and the various, sometimes contradictory, roles they play in the world, especially as our society becomes more obsessed with the act of photographing events. Like a wood fire in a room, photographsespecially those of people, of distant landscapes and. But being educated by photographs is not like being educated by older, more artisanal images. The inventory started in 1839 and since then just about. Humanity, argues susan sontag in in plato s cave in her collection of essays on photography, is still in plato s cave. Just monstrous shadows projected on the wall in front of you. The allegory of the cave imagine a life of only looking at the shadows on a wall. Jul 11, 2018 for sontag, the readings include notes on camp 1964, against interpretation 1966, and in platos cave 1977, the last of which is the subject of this installment of course notes.
In platos cave susan sontag sontag has referenced particular photographers and specific images. She mostly wrote essays, but also published novels. It humankind lingers unregenerately in platos cave, still reveling, its. These are questions that instantly wandered across my mind after reading, susan sontag s commentary, in platos cave, from the book, on photograph. Sontag draws an analogy between our viewing of photographs and the prisoners in platos cave. Against interpretation susan sontag the earliest experience of art must have been that it was incantatory, magical. The first essay in the collection, in plato s cave, uses plato s notion. We have other tragedies, but those are more common and remote, like in africa with darfur, but it has become so familiarized. Inform students that you are going to share platos allegory of the cave.
The truth is nothing more than the shadows the prisoners reality is not the totality of all experience that is possible the prisoners know nothing else, and therefore understand reality as such and only as such. If he attempts to persuade the people inside the cave saying that the outer world is the real world, and the cave world is unreal, his ignorant friends kill him. To do anything, to take action, it seems like we need a sudden shock and quick action when people still are ready for action. For sontag, the readings include notes on camp 1964, against interpretation 1966, and in platos cave 1977, the last of which is the subject of this installment of course notes. Since the words academy and academic come from the name of the area where plato taught, it is worth spending a moment to describe the park which was used for gymnastics from the sixth century bc. And now, i said, let me show in a figure how far our nature is enlightened or unenlightened. Humankind lingers unregenerately in platos cave, still reveling, its age. On photography susan sontag s 1977 book on photography is home to some of the most widely cited thinking in the field.
A human rights activist for more than two decades, ms. Most subjects photographed are, just by virtue of being photographed, touched with pathos. Susan sontag has returned photography to the cockpit of discussion it occupied when the exact mechanical image loomed as a threat to the person, to art, to the very relationship between images and. Chapter summary for susan sontags on photography, in platos cave summary. Susan sontag tells us in platos cave that photography makes us feel that the world is more available than it really is. We linger unregenerately in platos cave, still reveling, our ageold habit, in mere image of the truth. Plato claimed that knowledge gained through the senses is no more than opinion and that, in. Through the essay in platos cave, sontag uses the term truth almost interchangeable with the term reality but she disregards defining either of them. We were given questions to answer and the only resource we could use as reference would be susan sontag s essay entitled, on plato s cave.
On photography susan sontags 1977 book on photography is home to some of the most widely cited thinking in the. Plato the allegory of the cave republic, vii 514 a, 2 to 517. But being educated by photographs isnt like being educated by older, more crafted images. Susan sontag art history bibliographies cite this for me. May 02, 2018 the allegory is composed of a handful of signs and indications that describe the average mentality of an everyday person. Susan sontag in platos cave free download as pdf file. Best known as a novelist and essayist her books have been translated into thirtytwo languages she has also written stories and plays, written and directed movies, and worked as a theatre director in the united states and europe. John berger and susan sontag to tell a story 1983 john berger and susan sontag speak about story telling and about the ethic of photography. Twenty four hundred years ago, plato, one of historys most famous thinkers, said life is like being chained up in a cave forced to watch shadows flitting across a stone wall. Arguements, problems with photography and sontag s resolution.
Winner of the national book critics circle award for criticism one of the most highly regarded books of its kind, on photography first appeared in 1977 and is described by its author as a progress of essays about the meaning and career of photographs. On photography began with a single essay in which susan sontag wanted to explore some of the problems, both aesthetic and moral, presented by the omnipresence of photographed images in. The cave world acts as a symbol of selfimposed imprisonment most people carry out. It begins with the famous in plato s cave essay, then offers five other prose meditations on this topic, and concludes with a fascinating. An argument about beauty american academy of arts and.
Susan sontag s famous critique of photography entitled in platos cave starts with an analogy drawn from ancient greek philosophy. In trying to defend the aesthetic and moral value of photography, the photographic evangels discussed by susan sontag in chapter 5 of on photography had to fight for photographys claim to the statues of fine art as opposed to craft in light of its dependency on mechanical equipment. The public did not see such photographs because there was, ideologically, no space for them. Create your citations, reference lists and bibliographies automatically using the apa, mla, chicago, or harvard referencing styles. She is the author of four novels, a collection of stories, several plays, and six books of essays, among them illness as metaphor and aids and its metaphors. In platos cave susan sontag photograph camera scribd. In platos cave by susan sontag by megan leigh first off, i think the title of susan sontags chapter is interesting take on the relationship between the story or message of platos cave and photography, given what i remember about the story. Susan sontag, in platos cave from on photography 1977. The prisoners in platos story were born in a cave and chained in a way they only knew the wall in front of them. It remains a solid overview of the field nearly 40 years after it was first published. Sontag, in platos cave from on photography according to sontag, photographs change and broaden our thinking of the situation that is worth observing and that which we are allowed to observe sontag, 3. On photography began with a single essay in which susan sontag wanted to explore some of the problems, both aesthetic and moral, presented by the omnipresence of photographed images in her culture. The 1st chapter is an essay called in plato s cave.
In platos cave by susan sontag in susan sontag s view, both platos cave images and photographs represent mere images of the truth p. Literary interpretation and analysis of susan sontags book. It delves into the idea of transparency, where photographers have eliminated the boundaries of art and are faced with the prospect of being free to capture. Her bestknown works include on photography, against interpretation, styles of radical will, the way we live now. Susan sontag after the release of her 1992 novel the volcano lovers. Susan sontag was born in manhattan in 1933 and studied at the universities of chicago, harvard and oxford.
The point of the metaphor of the cave is that people sit inside the cave and watch shadows being reflected against a wall, and are transfixed by these moving images. Photography changes are conditions of imprisonment and create a kind of ethics of vision and the feeling that we can contain the whole world in our heads. The multitude of available photographic images leads us to construct the whole world in our head without ever having actually witnessed the people, places or events in the photographs. It begins with the famous in platos cave essay, then offers five other. For one thing, there are a great many more images around claiming our attention. Platos allegory of the cave is quite vivid and serves as an important example. On the walls of the cave only the shadows are the truth the republic plato the allegory of the cave is a theory put forward by plato, concerning human perception.
It is also a way of consolidating history and of telling a story about. It is a nostalgic time right now, and photographs actively promote nostalgia. Susan sontag on photography in platos cave summary. Susan sontag use the metaphor of platos cave to describe the role of photography as the different lighting from inside the cave and the direct sunlight from outside.
875 1194 460 179 1122 503 673 1465 719 544 1248 924 1600 1061 1028 1295 1468 443 937 1602 1195 1443 1196 444 1541 6 1531 1462 1369 1469 418 135 92 597 86 938 1586 1288 652 154 882 543 336 815 768 349 521 63 478 1492